However, they broke up and went their separate ways. In part, some of the early rejection of this story lies in the fact that none of the editors who read it had any idea what was going on in the story. He changes the subject and talks about trying Anis del Toro. He is not sure if the operation is safe, but doesn't want to scare her. He is asking her to abort their child, but manipulatively phrasing his request as something romantic and selfless. The woman appears from the bar to let the couple know that their train will be arriving in five minutes, which the man translates for the girl. A novel written in short, clipped sentences that use small, simple words might feel brusque, cold, or matter-of-fact.
See one group's answer here. They are hiding behind drinks and train schedules, rather than simply having a conversation about what they want to do. It is a wonder that this story was published at all. The origin of the phrase is commonly traced to a practice in Siam now Thailand in which a king would bestow the gift of a white elephant on a member of his court who displeased him. She is worried that if she has the operation, they may not be able to travel any more. This insight is best illustrated when she looks across the river and sees fields of fertile grain and the river — the fertility of the land, contrasted to the barren sterility of the hills like white elephants.
The woman looks at pregnancy as a beautiful aspect of life. The girl points out that the hills look like white elephants, which is already a lonely thought, but the guy coldly responds that he wouldn't know. He asks her to be quiet so that he can listen for the waitress through the curtain. The setting of the story represents Jig and her relationship with her American companion. Jig says in return that she will get the operation because she does not care about herself, which guilt-trips her boyfriend into saying that he does not want her to get it if she feels that way. Read The Sun Also Rises and the other stories in Men Without Women. .
They decide to order beer, and the woman who works at the bar brings the drinks to their table. Trace Choose an image—for example, birds, knives, or eyes—and trace that image throughout. Likewise, just as the man assumes everything will be fine and normal after the operation, the girl hints that the outcome is not always as pleasant as we expect it to be. Because the man isn't the one thinking of having an operation. In other words, it will take an exceptionally perceptive reader to realize immediately that the couple is arguing about the girl's having an abortion at a time when abortions were absolutely illegal, considered immoral, and usually dangerous.
Jig is a sympathetic character, ultimately more sympathetic, scholars have argued, than the American. Then she asks him to stop talking. Literary essays make unexpected connections and reveal less-than-obvious truths. Finally, always keep the overall effect in mind. Have students analyze the dilemma the Jig is facing as they read and speculate on the potential outcomes of the her choice.
GradeSaver, 10 December 2010 Web. Through stepping into the light, he shows that the man is seeing the woman's side of the abortion situation and is accepting her decision to give birth. Take a deep breath and start by asking yourself these questions: What struck you? Both of them are lonely and tired, though. It actually sounds pretty amateurish. For students, abortion has been legal for their entire lives. No one can own the world. The barmaid brings another round of beer and the announcement that the train is due in five minutes.
There are as many different, valid ways of reading a book as there are books in the world. This usually happens at or very near the end of your introduction. Jig remains the sole contact to the symbolic meaning of the setting until the end of the story, when Hemingway brings the man into the light. They both bring up people they know who have had the operation and gone back to being happy. The reason that he doesn't seem like he is too involved is because he has no illusions. He is worried that their life might change if she doesn't have the operation. What book are you discussing? The American man seems to think it will save their relationship and put everything back to normal, but Jig realizes that it is not a trivial decision.
Good literary essay writers know that each paragraph must be clearly and strongly linked to the material around it. Not only is this a great way to teach the parts of the plot, but it reinforces major events and helps students develop greater understanding of literary structures. The key to understanding the couple's decision lies in interpreting what the man does with the baggage and which side of the station he places the luggage. Write the Introduction Your introduction sets up the entire essay. Students can create a storyboard capturing the narrative arc in a work with a six-cell storyboard containing the major parts of the plot diagram.